I own four different dry brush cleaning sponges in round tins just like this, and all 4 are from different brands. I think the one I have from OE is honestly the nicest quality, even when compared to the original brands that made the idea get popular. I wash the tins and sponges regularly and many of my tins from other brands started rusting along the seams and so far the OE one looks good as new and the sponge itself works just as well as they all do, really. The packaging is where this one is clearly nicer quality above the others. It's actually beautiful as well as being practical.